Backstop: Burnham, Milburn and the generation made to carry the bill

Andy Burnham has plenty to say about what a school leaver owes the state and very little about what an employer owes the young people it expects to hire, writes Simon Pearson

 

“Benefits must become the backstop, not the starting point.”

Andy Burnham put that sentence near the end of his Guardian piece on Sunday, ahead of Alan Milburn’s final report on young people and work. I read it early this morning and kept coming back to that line as I walked the dog

Burnham opens with an admission few prime ministers would make. A million young people are out of education, employment or training, he writes, and politicians put them there. He takes the Conservative cuts one at a time and gives each one an age. A child who lost their Sure Start centre at four could find the youth club shut by the time they were twelve. As a teenager they might wait months or years for mental health care. It is the strongest passage in the piece. You can follow a child through it and see what each decision cost them.

By the time that child reaches the jobcentre, responsibility has changed hands. Burnham wants the first conversation to be about a young person’s ambitions. There is an obvious appeal in being asked what you want to do. What bothers me is the question Burnham says the system will cease to ask first, the one about what you are entitled to. An entitlement gives you a claim on the state. You can tell an adviser your ambition and still go home without knowing what you’ll live on.

Burnham’s history starts in 2010. Mine starts thirty years earlier, when deindustrialisation took the apprenticeships and works training schools that had given school leavers in places like Peterborough a way into skilled work. In 1983 Thatcher’s government introduced the Youth Training Scheme. Employers could take on trainees who received an allowance well below a wage. In 1988 the government withdrew income support from most 16- and 17-year-olds. For a teenager who turned down a scheme place, the question of what to live on was quite literal.

Same logic but friendlier name

New Labour kept the logic and gave it a friendlier name. From 1998, under the New Deal for Young People, 18- to 24-year-olds who had claimed Jobseeker’s Allowance for six months faced a choice of subsidised employment, training, voluntary work or a place on an environmental task force. Gordon Brown promised there would be no fifth option of staying at home on benefit. Milburn sat in the government that drew up those terms.

On that reckoning austerity was the third round. Each government left young people carrying more of the risk when employers had little work to offer. I have called this the Long 1980s. The institutions that once carried working-class teenagers into adult work disappeared, and successive governments set terms for the teenagers left looking for a way in. Start the story in 2010 and you can leave out the chapter that belongs to Labour.

There is an employer in the photograph above Burnham’s article. It shows him with schoolchildren at the Siemens Rail Technology Centre near Chippenham. In the article itself, employers scarcely figure. Burnham takes schools to task for looking down on the hard hat and promises good jobs where young people live. For a school leaver in Peterborough, that promise depends on who is taking people on, what they pay and whether they will train somebody who has never done the job.

Low expectations for employers

Employers made choices too. A firm that insists on experience for an entry-level job has decided that somebody else can pay to train the beginner. The cost falls on a college, on another employer, sometimes on a family that can afford to keep a teenager through a spell of unpaid work. In the survey commissioned for Milburn’s interim report, 84 per cent of respondents who were out of education, employment or training said they wanted a job, education or training. An adviser could have established that much at the first appointment. It still leaves the young person needing somewhere to go on Monday morning.

Milburn does ask employers about hiring. Retailers and hospitality firms told his review about the cost of Labour’s increase in employer National Insurance, which took effect in April 2025. For a shop deciding how many people it could afford on the rota, the overall wage bill mattered. On the wages a teenage shop assistant could expect, though, the employer’s National Insurance rate was already zero and stayed there. A retailer’s decision to cut recruitment across the business is its own decision. Burnham has plenty to say about what he expects of the teenager applying for the job and very little about what he expects of the retailer.

Mental health and young people

I came to Milburn’s mental health figures sceptical. He reports that 43 per cent of young people out of work through long-term sickness or disability cited mental health as the main reason, up from 24 per cent in 2011. He has called them the “bedroom generation”. My own instinct was to think about what happened after lockdown. For a while it seemed possible to explain almost anything by those months of lessons at the kitchen table. Later I wondered how much of the rise had to do with the accounts young people encountered on TikTok and Instagram. Somebody describing their diagnosis could give you words for a distress you had never been able to explain. They could also leave you convinced you had the same condition.

Lucy Foulkes and Jack Andrews have given that second possibility a name, the prevalence inflation hypothesis. They suggest that mental health campaigns may encourage some young people to interpret ordinary distress as a disorder. It was the word ‘hypothesis’ I should have paid more attention to. I had gone from recognising something familiar in their account to assuming I knew how many young people had been wrongly diagnosed.

I had the argument half written when I saw where it led. Spiked already runs a version of it, blaming a culture that infantilises the young. It takes very little editing to turn a socialist’s doubts about overdiagnosis into a minister’s case for cutting the health element of Universal Credit. That ought to have made me more exacting about the evidence. It also made me wonder why a diagnosis had come to matter quite so much in the first place.

Behind the doubling of ‘mental disorder’ diagnosis

Consider what a nineteen-year-old can say at the jobcentre. The only work she can get is agency shifts. She doesn’t know how many hours she’ll get next week, she can’t sleep and she is behind on the rent. Which part of that account can change what the jobcentre requires of her? She has good reason to take the sleeplessness to her GP. Medical evidence can count towards an assessment of her capacity for work, though a diagnosis by itself settles neither what she must do nor what she will be paid. By the time her case reaches a decision-maker, there may be a good deal on file about her sleep and very little about the agency.

There is money in diagnosis too. In 2023 a Panorama reporter was diagnosed with ADHD by three private clinics after video assessments costing between £685 and £1,095 each. ADHD charities disputed the programme’s portrayal of the sector. The sums tell us what the clinics could charge someone looking for an answer. They tell us precious little about the teenager who is still on an NHS waiting list. On social media, meanwhile, a creator who talks about a condition can earn money every time an account of their symptoms finds a bigger audience.

I still suspect that some ordinary distress acquires a clinical label it doesn’t warrant. I can’t put a figure on it. The NHS survey in England found that the proportion of 17- to 19-year-olds with a probable mental disorder rose from 10.1 per cent in 2017 to 23.3 per cent in 2023. A questionnaire can pick up what insecure work and unaffordable rent are doing to someone. It can also pick up a change in how readily they recognise and report symptoms. The survey records their answers. It gives me no grounds for deciding how much of the rise belongs to either explanation, still less for deciding whose benefit to cut.

Before Milburn’s final report has even appeared, Burnham has twice promised to bring the welfare bill down for good. He cites the £114 billion rise under the Conservatives as evidence of their failure. Suppose the nineteen-year-old in Peterborough comes off the health element, gets a run of agency shifts and finds, a few months later, that the agency has stopped ringing. For the weeks her payments were lower, the Treasury can book a saving. I’d like to know whether she managed to pay the rent that month. Where in Burnham’s account of success will anybody have to answer for that?

Join the discussion

MORE FROM ACR