Information has been leaked about the upcoming “Milburn Report” into youth unemployment (this is coming out on Tuesday, 17 November) and to say it is concerning is an understatement. The report is written by Alan Milburn, a former Blairite Labour Member of Parliament. The report is supposedly addressing two phenomena:
1) the “massive increase” of people aged 18-24 Not in Employment, Education and Training (NEETS); this round goes after disabled NEETS;
2) the “projected” massive increase in welfare expenditure; this is based on the assumption that the increased amount of disability cases due to covid is going to continue to rise although at a lower rate.
According to The Guardian,
“They (the government) say disability benefit spending on 16- to 24-year-olds – currently £800m a year on universal credit health and £3.2bn on personal independence payment (Pip) – is spiralling out of control.“
Yes, we are back here again … what part of welfare expenditure is actually rising?
Pensions expenditure is much greater than disability payments
The largest expenditure is pensions. They are not benefits but deferred income. They are included in this discussion of welfare; the reality is that UK state pensions are among the lowest in Europe. An increase happens with an ageing population. Incapacity benefits have risen but these are short-term benefits due to sickness or ill health and they are paid through National Insurance by working people. Again, these are not disability benefits, they are a temporary sickness support.
There have been increases in the number of people on Personal Independence Payment (PIP). It is a non-means tested benefit designed to help with the additional costs of being disabled. In fact, it is disabled older people rather than 18-24 year olds that are out of employment (not surprisingly). The number of people receiving PIP was at 3,981,360 in March 2026 (up from 3,979,870) in total. The main targets of Milburn’s report are young adults that are depressed, anxious, autistic and with ADHD. He has argued that what is needed is job training, support in finding work and cuts in benefits which means losses for many disabled young adults.
Why PIP expenditure has increased
This increase in expenditure on PIP is probably caused by two things:
1) forced migration from Disability Living Allowance, the earlier system that disabled children under 18 still can get, onto PIP. The change was done by the Tories to reduce the number of people getting the benefit support by making it harder to obtain, combined with a lower level of comparative benefits available between the two. We can for the moment ignore the loss of the Independent Living Fund under the Tories);
2) an increase in those who have long-term impairments due to covid. Long covid certainly has increased the number of people who have developed “life-limiting” conditions; but the numbers of people developing new impairments due to Covid had actually been decreasing.
As usual, blaming the victims of the capitalist economic system forms the basis of government response. There is the usual nonsense that disabled people are not employed and hence are not contributing to the economy and society! Even more so, that somehow the pleasures of work are missed by these young people.
Yet, if we accept the absurd argument that our contribution to the society and economy is solely defined by paid work, that is still untrue according to a Government Report on the Employment of Disabled People, In the period between 2016-2024, we can see that disabled people are employed and that this was increasing up until the Covid Pandemic but has started to rebound a bit (although it is not statistically significant).

Some Information
According to the Government Report based on Census Data, Unemployment of Disabled people (16-24 years)
“There were 5.6 million disabled people in employment in the UK in April to June 2026 and the disability employment rate was 53%, compared to 82.4% for non-disabled people. The change in the number of disabled people in employment (between 2013 and 2026) was driven by 4 main components of change: disability prevalence (60%); non-disabled employment rate (20%); disability employment gap (15%); and increases in the working-age population (5%).
Compared to all disabled people, the employment rate is lower for disabled people with a mental health condition and those with 3 or more health conditions. Disabled people were more likely than non-disabled people to be working in Human Health, Retail and Education, and lower-skilled occupations and to be self-employed, working part-time and in the public sector. They were also more likely to be underemployed.”
Finally, some useful information specifically about disabled NEETs that are under attack by the Milburn report and which have engendered something akin to a moral panic:
“According to the report ‘Young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), UK: August 2026’ by ONS, an estimated 13 % of all people aged 16 to 24 years were not in education, employment or training (NEET) in April to June 2026, which is up by 0.2 percentage points compared to the same quarter in 2025. When considering only those aged 18 to 24 years, the proportion who were NEET was 15.2%, which remained largely the same on the year. This includes people who are economically inactive and those who are unemployed (inactive means not looking for work, unemployed means they are still looking).
From Disabled people in Employment:
In FYE 2026, 45.3% of NEET young people (aged 16 to 24) were classed as disabled, an increase of 24.2 percentage points since FYE 2014. In FYE 2026, disabled young people were more than 3 times as likely to be NEET (30.2%) compared to non-disabled young people (8.6%).”
In FYE 2026, nearly half (41.3%) of disabled people reporting autism as a main or secondary health condition were aged 16 to 24, compared to 13.1% for all disabled people. Around a quarter (29.3%) of disabled people with severe or specific learning difficulties were aged 16 to 24.Disabled people with autism or severe or specific learning difficulties as a main or secondary health condition were also more likely to have no qualifications: around 1 in 5 disabled people with autism (20.4%) had no qualifications and around 1 in 3 (31.2%) of those with severe or specific learning difficulties. This compares to 11.9% of all disabled people who had no qualifications.
Of those reporting having severe or specific learning difficulties as their main health condition in FYE 2026, 23.9% reported autism as a secondary health condition. Of those reporting autism as their main health condition 15.9% also reported having severe or specific learning difficulties.”
Looking at NEETs, there are differences for why disabled and non-disabled young adults say they are NEET. According to the Employment of Disabled People Report:
“Looking for work or a suitable course (29.5%) was the most common reason given for being NEET for all young people who were NEET in FYE 2026, followed by disability and ill-health (28.4%). For disabled people who were NEET, 59.3% indicated disability and ill-health as their main reason for being NEET, and 14.1% indicated that looking for work or a suitable course was their main reason.”
If this is the case, is the problem high levels of benefits, is the problem one of not finding courses or work? Is job training the issue? If this is the problem, what is the solution? It certainly is not forcing disabled people into (non-existant) jobs.

What Next?
The report has been leaked to prepare us for the changes being proposed. There will be no personal independence payments (PIP) for 18-24 year-olds. It has also been floated that 18-24 year-olds will lose access to Universal Credit Health (UC-H) which is means-tested. If Milburn’s proposals are accepted both disability benefits will be eliminated for 18-24 year-olds. The reports and its recommendations have not been published yet, nor have the recommendations been accepted. But we need to start opposing this now.

These attacks hit those disabled NEETs that are on disability benefit; if you are not on benefit, they do not hit you in the same way (we are talking specifically of an attack against those on disability benefits). It is projected that all NEETS who refuse training, support or a job will be sanctioned – i.e. lose their benefits. So this has a strong economic and class component.
According to Mill.org:
“Instead, young people would receive a new youth allowance based on the standard Universal Credit rate, alongside significantly expanded employment and training support.
The proposed system would also include a separate, non-means-tested allowance for people with significant ongoing disability-related costs.
People with the most profound lifelong disabilities who cannot be expected to work would qualify for a higher-rate benefit.
However, the proposed replacement allowances would have different eligibility rules, meaning some existing claimants could receive less money.”
Disabled People and Work
Disabled people are in work, so is it disabled people refusing to work that is the problem? No, they do work, so what is going on? That means that this is not a supply issue, disabled people want to work … Why has this nonsense started up again? Since, it never really ended, it seems to be more of a continual attack.
The level of confusion is impressive in this discussion. On the one hand, we have an issue of insufficient jobs to employ disabled and younger people aged 16-24. The jobs that do exist in the private sector are more part-time jobs, which both disabled and non-disabled NEETS leave more often.
The destruction of wages and working conditions literally means that wages are still very low (they were stagnant for over a decade) and the minimum wage obviously needs to be increased for everyone.
Despite Milburn’s recognition that the problem is a demand one (that is insufficient jobs to employ people), the usual nonsense is trotted out.
If we lower wages for younger workers that would get them employed it doesn’t work. We cannot put their wages below the level of benefits, one of the favourite Tory beliefs was that wages must be higher than benefits. The job market for “low skilled” poorly paid labour (the choice of neoliberals everywhere) has adults working in it.
Productivity is very low and job retention is low because they can easily hire new people. Why introduce tech when labour costs are so low?.
Private sector provides less ‘reasonable accommodations’ for disabled
So how does Milburn think this issue can be addressed? Due to the law, employed disabled people are entitled to “reasonable accommodation” meaning that the hirer needs to ensure that there are, among other things., ramps, appropriate lighting, more flexible schedules, chairs that are more appropriate for disabled people, desks at the correct level for those in a wheelchair.
This means that if these things are not already available in the business, the business needs to adapt the workplace. This is a legal requirement; it may make hiring disabled people more expensive than non-disabled people.
What’s one place of employment that actually already has many of the accommodations already in place? That is the public sector and unsurprisingly, more disabled people work in the public sector; alas due to the attack on the public sector by the Tories, the number of people working in the public sector in total, has decreased. According to the report The Employment of Disabled People: 2026:
“The proportion of disabled people working in the public sector remained relatively stable between FYE 2015 and FYE 2020 – within the range of 23.1% to 23.7%. In FYE 2021 – the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic – the proportion increased to 26.5%. In FYE 2026 the proportion was 27.1%, which is 3.4 percentage points above that seen prior to the pandemic and the highest since FYE 2014.“

Why not create useful public sector jobs?
One question that is obvious … instead of waiting for the private sector to create jobs (that they do not want or need .. think of non-existent economic growth?!), why not do direct government job creation? That means that the state actually creates the jobs; they hire them directly. A great place to try this would be the public sector. Most government buildings are accessible, disabled people do already work in the public sector. It is a highly unionised sector with decent wages and benefits. Isn’t Labour the party of labour?
The public sector had been shrunk significantly by the Con-Dems following the 2007-8 crisis. Workers wages were frozen and then allowed only a 1 % increase for a decade. Workers that left were not replaced and remaining workers are overworked. These public sector workers need support. Our services are actually worse with the shrunk public sector and the use of private sector “agency work” providing our desperately needed services of all types. Interestingly they had to massively increase public sector workers such as care workers after Brexit as they needed people to do the work that was formerly done by EU workers.
We need to put forward a better solution than the usual nonsense of workfare, “training people” to stack shelves, and then sacking them when the training is over. Why is Milburn talking about a 6-month job guarantee for NEETS? What will happen to them when that 6-month job guarantee is over?!
Why not offer (not force … offer) the possibility of full-time decent paid jobs in the public sector if the Labour Party is so concerned about NEETS and especially disabled NEETS? This would benefit everyone. We are seeing them talk of removing their benefits, especially if they are depressed, have anxiety, and are ADHD/autistic. They want to force them into job training programs and work.
Stop blaming the victims of the capitalist economic system.
But I guess that may be too much for Alan Milburn … probably reeks a little too much of “socialism” for a Blairite.


