France – broadening the left coalition?

Dave Kellaway introduces and discusses an appeal made by Clementine Autain, French MP, feminist and leader of the Apres party

 

We publish below an appeal from Clementine Autain, a leader of a left party, L’Après [After]. It has four parliamentary representatives and local members. She used to be a key leader of  La France Insoumise, LFI, [France Unbowed], the movement led by Jean Luc Melenchon (JLM) but along with other leaders and members she had disagreements with him about internal democracy, organisation and some policies. They were critical of aspects of the overall populist ideology too.

The colleagues who supported her criticisms of JLM were  removed as LFI candidates  in the 2024 snap general electon. On 12 July 2024 after the second round  Autain and those colleagues, Corbière, Garrido, Simonnet, and Davi officially launched a new eco-socialist political party called L’Après, L’Association pour la République écologique et sociale, [Association for an economic, social Republic], aligning their MPs with the Ecologist parliamentary group rather than the LFI.

She has been a prominent feminist campaigner in France particularly on the issue of violence against women. Autain went public in 2006 about her rape at knifepoint when she was 22.

Positive momentum of JLM campaign

We must read the text below in the context of the mass mobilisations in France and the campaign for the Presidential Elections in April 2027.

Currently aggregated poll data put the far right Marine le Pen at a stable 34%. It would be surprising if this figure declined enough to prevent her going into the two person second round run off.  On the other side JLM is at 18% in the latest aggregated poll (at Politico.eu) which is an increase of one per cent on the previous month. Specific polls I have seen has shown him at 19 or 20%.  The protest upsurge in France, the national strike days and ferment among the youth appears to have resulted in gains for both the far right and for the radical left JLM campaign.

The polling this time for JLM is higher than at this stage in his previous three attempts. Even the mainstream TV commentators are recognising the current effectiveness of his campaign, both in terms of communicating his key policies in the media and the size of his meetings. There were huge crowds in Lille, Saint Denis and recently at Le Bourget. Given that his competitors on the social liberal left, Raphael Glucksman, and on the centre right, Edouard Philippe are respectively six and five percentage points behind, he is currently looking a strong contender to get to the second round.

It would require withdrawals and a unity candidate from the traditional right parties or Glucksman to win voters from the more moderate right or centre to change that situation. Opponents of JLM on the social liberal left and other parties are hoping that the projections of a Le Pen win against JLM and all others will encourage a rallying to a non-JLM candidate right from the first round. What you might call a pre-emptive anti-far right, ‘Republican’ strategy. However, there is a long way to go and the instability of the political situations means changes are possible. However this time Glucksman is no Macron able to soak up votes across the political spectrum.

Green candidate withdraws?

The appeal below follows the opening of the previously declared Green candidate, Marine Tondelier, to an agreement with JLM.  Her withdrawal could add up another 3% to Melenchon. If L’Après were to also back his campaign then another point or two might come over. Nothing has yet been decided but such moves further restricts Glucksman’s potential pool of voters. Autain’s appeal is more positive that the statement made by the L’Après leadership secretariat as a whole. There may well be sharp opposition to Autain’s position.

Getting into the run off would be an important achievement for JLM and the whole left but he would still have a mountain to climb to win in the second round if all past and present polls are accurate. The gap could be as big as 20 percentage points. How could this be turned around?

Obviously if the protests deepened and broadened then the potential for the left radicalisation to overtake the far right radicalisation exists. Up to now this has not happened.  One result of the protests may be to mobilise those voters who have abstained in the past. We saw how attracting former non-voters made a difference in Brazil, the US midterms and Serbia. JLM has particularly mobilised young people and those from the ethnic minority communities.

Broadening a left campaign

Broadening the appeal of the JLM campaign, making it a little less LFI dominated and more reflective of a wider left coalition – something Autain argues here – may also eat into the Glucksman base and mobilise non-voters. Making the campaign broader in the first round would help build momentum for a popular coalition in the second round.

There are also left votes to be had from the official Communist party candidate, Rousel, who is polling at 2% at the moment. If the Greens withdraw and L’Après back JLM this would put pressure on Roussel who has already lost a lot of his parliamentary party’s support.

People on the left in Britain have been inspired by JLM’s big meetings. His speeches talk about changing the relationship of forces, of the need for a ‘rupture‘ with the current capitalist system. Will that be enough to defeat the far right in April?  Can JLM appeal to those Glucksman voters to support him in the second round? Is he able or will he make a deal with the more moderate left?

Fight to win but be prepared for a Le Pen government. Build strong local anti-fascist self-organisation through supporting the LFI campaign. This is the position of the Nouveau Parti Anticapitaliste (NPA) [New Anticapitalist Party] which is building support for JLM but under its own banner and programme. The success of recent public meetings shows this approach is having some resonance.

Front page from Liberation rabout Autain’s conflict with JLM – ‘We need to democratise France Unbowed’

Appeal from Clementine Autain

Last July, I stated in Libération that in order to win, Jean-Luc Mélenchon needed partners. That if he were at the head of the left in the fall, he would have the responsibility of bringing them together.

We are there now.

Taking on this responsibility, Marine Tondelier [Green leader] has just opened the door to a coalition around the La France Insoumise (LFI- France Unbowed) leader’s candidacy which has momentum among people on the left. The insoumis has responded with “Bring it on!” I am pleased.

My movement L’Après will make its choice for the presidential election in its conference on December 12 and 13, followed by a vote by members on the 15th. In this context, I support the call for a vote for Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s candidacy.

L’Après will decide. But in the meantime, I want to reiterate my conviction about what a coalition means. Because it is one of the keys to victory:

  • It is the respect for pluralism in the conduct of the campaign and the will to govern together.  This means  accepting some compromises and not railroading partners to toe one line.
  • It requires a programmatic agreement and a fair share out of constituencies in the post presidential parliamentary elections so that we can win that crucial general election.,

The Lucie Castets-led strategy of bringing together the left and the ecologists in the Front Populaire 2027 project has failed.  Along with L’Apres I was involved with this and I had put myself forward as a potential candidate in any primary of the left The Socialist Party preferred to do without us… and hitched its wagon to the Place Publique [Town Square] and its leader Raphaël Glucksmann. Meanwhile, LFI has gained support and, this autumn has supported and been propelled by the ongoing mass mobilizations in the streets, education institutions and the workplaces.

As I said back in July, L’Après will never line up “behind a candidacy that would revive the spectre of the Hollande and Macron years.” We must win and deeply transform the country.

Consequently…

I hope that the hand extended by Marine Tondelier on TF1’s [main state network] news programme will be grasped by Jean-Luc Mélenchon. So that a broad coalition can emerge, and not just an LFI  campaign, with the LFI programme, for a LFI government.

Marine Le Pen’s far right Rassemblement National (RN National Rally) has the international wind in its sails and the red carpet is rolled out every day a little more by the establishment. Faced with that threat we need a much broader front to win. . Today the Ecologists, Génération.s, the Communistes Unitaires [Communists for Unity], the Nouveau Parti Anticapitaliste [New Anticapitalist Party –NPA], and some socialists have already said they are ready to be part of it. All while maintaining their political identities

.Our disagreements with Jean-Luc Mélenchon (JLM) are well known and they still remain:

  • on international issues such as Ukraine,
  • on the appreciation of the current danger of anti-Semitism or
  • the relationship with the intermediary institutions [local state, trade unions, civil society organizations defending democratic rights – DK Tr]

However the very nature of a coalition is to accept differences.

This assumed diversity is not contradictory with the essential promotion of everything that brings us together against our particularly dangerous enemies.

What we have in common is substantial:

  • the fight against inequalities
  • dealing with climate change,
  • the defense of services and tax justice,
  • measures against the high cost of living
  • for democratic rights

In the National Assembly, our votes already converge in 90% of cases.

In the troubled, violent and threatening period we are going through, I will be among those who take their responsibilities serioiusly. Our duty is to stand up against the far right.

That is why I want a broad coalition. I want my movement L’Après to participate in the ongoing discussions.

The hope aroused by the youth demands this choice.

Let us rise to the occasion.

19 November 2026 [tranlation by DK/ACR]


Dave Kellaway is on the Editorial Board of Anti*Capitalist Resistance, a contributor to International Viewpoint and Europe Solidaire Sans Frontieres.

Join the discussion

MORE FROM ACR