Where Names Do Matter

‘What's in a name? That which we call a rose. By any other name would smell as sweet.’ So claims Juliet in Shakespeare’s play. But all week commentators, Tory politicians and supposed ‘journalists’ reports Geoff Ryan have been queuing up to disprove Juliet’s assertion.

 

And the cause of all these complaints about names? The decision by the Brecon Beacons National Park management that from now on they will only use the original  Welsh/Cymraeg name Parc Cenedlaethol Bannau Brycheiniog and abandon the logo of a burning brazier was taken for 2 reasons.

  1. The current name referencing wood-burning, carbon-emitting no longer fitted with the park’s ecological ethos.
  2. Brecon Beacons doesn’t really mean anything in Welsh/Cymraeg and is already known to many Welsh people as Bannau Brycheiniog. By only using Bannau Brycheiniog the aim is to celebrate Welsh people, Welsh culture, Welsh food and Welsh farming.

This decision to use the Welsh/Cymraeg language in Cymru/Wales has provoked outrage. Susanna Reid, Good Morning Britain host, kicked off the hostile reaction claiming she thought it was a joke.

She was soon followed by Fay Jones, Tory MP for Brecon and Radnorshire, who claimed the decision appeared to have been taken without any consultation with people who live and work in the national park – totally ignoring the year long consultation with staff, residents, volunteers and visitors carried out by the park managers.

Nor did she ever complain about the decision to rename the Second Severn Crossing the Prince of Wales Bridge, a decision taken without any consultation with the people of Cymru.

She also hasn’t raised any objections to the refusal by the UK government to even consider accepting any petition to change the name of this bridge to o ne less controversial in Cymru – the Gareth Bale  bridge has been suggested.

The Daily Telegraph, which has a long history of hostility to the Welsh language and the use of Cymraeg names, piled in, accompanied by  several Tory MPs and leader of the Welsh Tories Andrew RT Davies. Essentially the same people who were hostile to the decision to revert to the original Yr Wydffa and Eryri rather than the English Snowdon and Snowdonia.

No doubt they would all oppose the renaming of Ayres Rock as Uluru or Mount McKinley as Denali even though, like Cymraeg in Cymru, they are names based on languages that are not spoken by the majority of people in Australia or Alaska.

Parc Cenedlaethol Bannau Brycheiniog
Parc Cenedlaethol Bannau Brycheiniog https://unsplash.com/photos/eO_cXUR8h1w

While right wing commentators and politicians were getting worked up about Bannau Brycheiniog the fascists of Voice of Wales , Students Against Tyranny and Banners on Bridges, Cardiff (who regularly publish Tommy Robinson’s filth) were attempting to get recruits by leafletting in Abertawe/Swansea. They focussed on Welsh government plans to restrict the building of roads and denouncing the ’15 minute city’ which they claimed was a deliberate plan to prevent people leaving their neighbourhoods.

Other bizarre ideas were claims that the government (Welsh or UK isn’t clear) is planning to make ‘everything digital’ thereby preventing people ‘saving for a rainy day’ or leaving cash for ‘the tooth fairy’. Plus anti-vax and Covid denial nonsense.

Voice of Wales and their collaborators were not the only fascists raising their heads in Cymru. After their miserable showing in Llanilltud Fawr/Llantwit Major a few weeks ago Patriotic Alternative announced they would be holding another protest against plans to house refugees on April 29.

Patriotic Alternative* are not the only ones attacking refugees. In 2022 the Welsh Labour Government started a trial of Universal Basic Income for 18 year old who have recently been in care. They are paid £1600 (£1280 after tax) a month for 2 years. The money is intended to help them transition to adult life.

A few of those receiving UBI payments (48 out of 294) did not give their nationality as Welsh, British or English. But not all the 48 (who cover 29 nationalities) are necessarily refugees. Some may well have already been granted asylum or are legally in Cymru through other routes. I’m any case the Welsh Government has declared Cymru a ‘Nation of Sanctuary’ so it is totally consistent to include 18 year old refugees in the UBI trial.

But none of this has stopped Rishi Sunak, Welsh Secretary David TC Davies, Andrew RT Davies and, of course, Nigel Farage denouncing the payments. Farage claimed there would be much bigger boats coming straight into Cardiff Bay while Andrew RT Davies described the plan as ‘one of the most extreme’ he had ever seen’.

In this atmosphere of hostility to the Welsh language, to refugees and to environmental measures it is essential that Patriotic Alternative aren’t able to mobilize in Llanilltud Fawr/Llantwit Major on 29 April and  making sure the YesCymru/All Under One Banner March in Abertawe/Swansea on May 20 is a big success.

* in breaking news last night (20/04) Patriotic Alternative have parted ways. (ed)


Art Book Review Books Capitalism China Climate Emergency Conservative Government Conservative Party COVID-19 Economics EcoSocialism Elections Fascism Film Film Review France Gaza Imperialism Israel Italy Keir Starmer Labour Party Long Read Marxism Marxist Theory Palestine pandemic Protest Russia Solidarity Statement Trade Unionism Ukraine United States of America War

Latest articles

  • The US Administration’s Hypocrisy and Israel’s Insolence
    In this article, Gilbert Achcar lambasts the hypocritical stance of the US administration and the insolence of Israel regarding a UN Security Council resolution that called for a ceasefire in Gaza during the month of Ramadan, highlighting Washington’s complicity in Israel’s ongoing genocidal war against the Palestinian people.
  • Another Left Is Possible
    The article discusses the launch of Zabalaza for Socialism (ZASO), a new ecosocialist, feminist, and anti-racist organisation in South Africa, and the keynote speech by Gilbert Achcar, which analyses the current global political landscape and emphasises the urgent need for the Left to reinvent itself in order to effectively challenge the rise of neoliberalism, authoritarianism, and the far-right. Additional commentary from Brian Ashley.
  • Terrorist Attack in Moscow: When the government’s response is more frightening than the terrorist attack itself
    The recent terrorist attack in Moscow’s Crocus City Hall has not only shaken Russia with its brutality, writes POSLE, but has also raised concerns about the government’s response, which may prove to be even more frightening than the attack itself.
  • A shift to the right but an uncertain future after elections in Portugal
    In Portugal’s recent parliamentary elections, writes Adriano Campos, the right-wing parties secured a majority, with the far-right CHEGA party making significant gains, while the left-wing parties faced challenges and must now unite to organise a strong opposition and present a credible alternative to the new conservative government.
  • Karl Marx and Ecology: An Interview with Michael Löwy
    While some ecologists remain critical of Marxism and skeptical about how much Marx can offer the environmental movement, Michael Löwy argues that Marx’s writing can help us understand the relationship between nature, capitalism, and wealth formation. Translated by David Fernbach

Geoff Ryan is a member of Undod, YesCymru, Labour For An Independent Wales, and Carmarthen East & Dynefwr Labour Party.


One comment

Join the discussion

MORE FROM ACR