It should be no surprise to those who spend their time reading the output of some on the radical left, Russian aggression in Ukraine has them in a kerfuffle. One must be a contortionist to accept some of the positions being adopted. Theory can inform, but it should not be mangled to fit a narrative. However, this is not a piece to offer individual critique of all the wrongheadedness on show.
Instead, I want to concentrate on the reality the Ukrainian people find themselves in. What happened in previous conflicts cannot excuse Putin’s actions today. Once Russian artillery is used to shell civilian areas the ‘whataboutery’ ends. Is one really a warmonger in calling for the west to supply military equipment to those defending Ukraine? Military aid that can be used to preserve hospitals, schools, universities and homes? Infrastructure that has already been targeted and destroyed by Putin’s war machine. This is not fake news written up by the mainstream media, or a CIA wet dream of fire and brimstone to justify a new cold war. This is the now in Mariupol, Chernihiv, and Kyiv.
How many Ukrainian children must perish as western leftists debate the imperial nature of the conflict? We may find ourselves on the same side as one’s imperialists not because we support imperialism but because the alternative is not a hypothetical analysis of working-class revolution in Russia bringing the war to an end. The Ukrainians huddled in the basement of a bombed-out tower block probably do not care that, at this moment, they are governed by a bourgeois neoliberal government. They just want to live.
We must avoid ‘jam tomorrow’ and concentrate on the material aid we can give today. Food, water, medicines and yes, defensive armaments will far better serve the working-class of Ukraine than rhetoric. Therefore, the actuality of war should be at the forefront of the solidarity we offer. It is crucial we recognise the war that is being fought is not the one we want nor need to prove our theoretical positions correct.
Where are your red lines? Is it 500 children dead? Or are the deaths of innocents’ mere agitprop?
Those standing in rubble do not look to the past. What has gone provides no reference point to the hell they now occupy. Some on the left hide in the past, seek comfort in the familiar touch of the theory that confirms their worldview. Unable to recognise the world has changed, they can no longer be seen as the vanguard. They are destined to be forgotten, apart from the tall tales they will recount about when, if only, it was almost so.
I do not mask myself with the stench of patriotic fervour, my country right or wrong. It is often wrong.
Find no glory in war.
Smart bombs are dumb.
There can be no more powerful a lie than ‘dulce et decorum est pro patria mori’. So please don’t lecture me with theory. Unless you can back words with action. If not, the theory you espouse remains lifeless on the page, bereft of form.
Art Book Review Books Campism Capitalism China Climate Emergency Conservative Government Conservative Party COVID-19 Creeping Fascism Economics EcoSocialism Elections Europe Event Video Far-Right Fascism Film Film Review Fourth International France Gaza History Imperialism Israel Italy Keir Starmer Labour Party Long Read Marxism Marxist Theory Migrants Palestine pandemic Police Protest Russia Solidarity Statement Trade Unionism Trans*Mission Ukraine United States of America War
The UK state is not unitary from the point of taxation. There is significant fiscal devolution – council tax and its equivalent is devolved to all four polities, and property sales taxes devolved in Cymru and Scotland. Scotland has significant influence over income tax rates and bands, but the ability to create new taxes is largely controlled by Westminster though a Tourist tax has been approved. Interestingly, Corporation Tax was devolved to the Northern Ireland Assembly by the Tories (largely to encourage it to match the very low rates in the 26 county Republic of Ireland state). However VAT, National Insurance and many other taxes are UK-wide (not just “Britain”) and controlled by Westminster.
The STUC has identified measures https://www.stuc.org.uk/news/news/stuc-launch-tax-proposals-to-save-scotlands-public-services/ under current devolution arrangements that could be used to tax wealth more by the Scottish Parliament. The Scottish Greens have in the last few days introduced an exemplary measure into the housing bill at Holyrood to remove the exemption on the monarch’s properties being taxed in Scotland (he owns 80), a symbolic gesture but not politically insignificant, and have proposed a new council tax band for mansions. The Scottish Socialist Party has long proposed removing the regressive council tax and replacing it with a redistributive Scottish Service Tax.
This is all in advance of the devolved Scottish Parliament elections in May 2026. Polls tell us voters in Cymru strongly support the extension of the fiscal powers devolved to the Scottish Parliament to Senedd Cymru, as a minimal demand, and also elect a new Senedd on a new PR system in May 2026.
The campaign for a wealth tax will therefore have a totally different character and demands in the different parts of “Britain” (which has not been a fiscal or economic unit for 225 years by the way). There are no Anglo-centric “one size fits all” fiscal solutions, even within the current form of the UK state.